TPM: Speechless

spoco2says...

Holy crap I couldn't sit through all of that. I am STUNNED that so many Americans actually consider him to be a worthy opposition, that they actually WANT him as any kind of leader. The man's smile makes me retch a little bit, his speaking is slow and cumbersome, his look that of a dazed wombat who's just been woken up.

If America votes him in over Obama, then your descent into global ridicule and scorn will continue at breakneck speed.

bamdrewsays...

yeah... news has it now that Obama's camp is considering holding a series of public town-hall talks with McCain on the issues, an idea McCain's side proposed... which would really be throwing McCain a bone... because if its down to who can give the best speech and who comes out the best after 3 debates, Obama has it in the bag.

NetRunnersays...

>> ^bamdrew:
yeah... news has it now that Obama's camp is considering holding a series of public town-hall talks with McCain on the issues, an idea McCain's side proposed... which would really be throwing McCain a bone... because if its down to who can give the best speech and who comes out the best after 3 debates, Obama has it in the bag.


They've been talking about 10 of these town-hall debates, I presume that's in addition to the already scheduled 3 official presidential debates in the fall.

I'd love to see it happen, and I can't fathom the rationale behind it at the McCain campaign. The worst thing they could do is give people a chance to compare Obama and McCain side by side.

It'll be YouTube vs. Feeding Tube.

RedSkysays...

>> ^NetRunner:
>> ^bamdrew:
yeah... news has it now that Obama's camp is considering holding a series of public town-hall talks with McCain on the issues, an idea McCain's side proposed... which would really be throwing McCain a bone... because if its down to who can give the best speech and who comes out the best after 3 debates, Obama has it in the bag.

They've been talking about 10 of these town-hall debates, I presume that's in addition to the already scheduled 3 official presidential debates in the fall.
I'd love to see it happen, and I can't fathom the rationale behind it at the McCain campaign. The worst thing they could do is give people a chance to compare Obama and McCain side by side.
It'll be YouTube vs. Feeding Tube.


McCain simply may have no other choice. He's crippled by public financing and the media limelight has effectively eluded him during the over-extended Democratic primary season. This may be his only way to take center stage again. But yeah I agree, it's a fool's errand, Obama is unanimously the superior speaker and orator, he was arguably a weaker debater to Clinton but just reminiscing back to the Republican debates, McCain hardly stood out either. If nothing else, this will give Obama a chance to highlight his utter hypocrisy embodying his image as a 'maverick' and accentuate his recent about-turns on countless social and economic issues. Not to mention, for a party heavily reliant on 'values' voters, rational and meticulous policy issues are hardly going to galvanise support.

fizzikssays...

Oh man, that video was awesome... I think McCain trying to jump on the change wagon is a good sign for Obama since 1) McCain is tacitly approving of the "change" concept, and 2) There's no way McCain can sell himself as "the right change"... or change at all for that matter.

I really hope the dems steamroll this election... but I still wonder if the Dark Side isn't waiting in the wings... It's the dem's election to lose, and if McCain somehow pulls it off, he will be a hero. If he loses, people will just say "He never had a chance... ... ... ... and he's old!"

rottenseedsays...

the funny thing is, neo-cons are voting for McCain just because. McCain can come out in a diaper and a pacifier talkin' about "goo goo gah gah" and a lot of people would still vote for him.

There's something wrong with your system of politics when that's the case. I think that it's time for a change you can believe in.

10351says...

Is it just me or does McCain look like a mix of Emperor Palpatine and Mike Myers?

On a more serious note. The talking heads are being way too forgiving to McCain for that speech. The only person that put it right was the one that said that was the worst speech he had ever heard, which was closer to the truth.

eoesays...

Trying to take a more objective stance on all this from the overwhelmingly liberal point of view on this page, I find it aggravating that -again- the media is concentrating -entirely- on anything -but- the issues themselves. I can, for myself, see whether Obama or McCain is a better orator. I don't need the media to tell me that. What I do need is them to be fact checking the -content- of the speech, which is something I can't necessarily do while they are giving the speech.

For the love of crap, regardless who's on the stiff end of the stick, be it the Democrat or the Republican, or Ralph Nader, I want to hear about the god-damned issues already.

NetRunnersays...

>> ^eoe:
Trying to take a more objective stance on all this from the overwhelmingly liberal point of view on this page, I find it aggravating that -again- the media is concentrating -entirely- on anything -but- the issues themselves. I can, for myself, see whether Obama or McCain is a better orator. I don't need the media to tell me that. What I do need is them to be fact checking the -content- of the speech, which is something I can't necessarily do while they are giving the speech.
For the love of crap, regardless who's on the stiff end of the stick, be it the Democrat or the Republican, or Ralph Nader, I want to hear about the god-damned issues already.


I agree, though if you're interested in the issues, you shouldn't be listening to a campaign speech from the candidate. You should look at their website, and then read the online critiques of the candidate/policy from a source you trust.

For God's sake, don't take the candidate, or TV media's word for it.

winkler1says...

He was also #894 of 899 at the Naval Academy... not that bright.

Also seems to be coming out with some jawdropping misstatements, then acting like the conviction with which he states things makes them true. A trait he shares with his buddy George W.

LeadingZerosays...

As an Obama supporter, I'm encouraged by how overwhelmingly well received Sen. Obama's June 3rd speech has been when contrasted to Sen. McCain's speech.

However, I'm weary about some of the over-confidence I've been hearing. Sure, Obama is hands down the better speaker, indeed he is leading marginally in current national polls, and yes we've seen many new voters registering, but presidential elections are all about one magic number...That number is 270, the minimum number of electoral votes needed to win on November 4th. Sen. McCain has a distinct advantage when we look at current individual state poll numbers and voting patterns from the 2000 and 2004 in the key battleground states.

For all of the hopeful discussion about putting new states into play, presently we're still looking at a similar set of red vs. blue states. While there's still time for things to change, the states of FL, OH, and PA are all well within McCain's 'win' column. The path to the White House effectively requires at least two of those three states given the realities of the red/blue divide. Further, some polls are suggesting that 12% of Democrats intend to crossover to vote for McCain. That's more than the 8% that voted for Bush in 2004.

Personally, I think that making fun of McCain's age at every turn might well be perceived as arrogant and mean-spirited to millions of older voters who we do actually need in November. (My grandfather is older than McCain and is supporting Obama, but he's rightfully indignant about the rude and hurtful comments of younger Obama supporters who are so blatantly ageist.) McCain's lack of positive vision for our country, poor character, inconsistencies in his legislative career, his support for key aspects of the failed Bush administration's policies, his associations with lobbyists, so on, would make him a bad choice for president of the United States at any age.

NetRunnersays...

^ Those are all valid concerns, particularly with regards to our regular participants in election fraud, Ohio and Florida.

No one should rest on their laurels by any means, but I think the more direct comparison between the candidates the better.

The more direct conversations between them on the issues of the day, the better.

McCain hasn't broken with Bush on a single issue, and doesn't have an attractive way of repackaging it, either. McCain isn't charismatic like Bush. Bush always seemed like a folksy plainspoken sorta guy (back before we knew what he really was like). McCain just seems like an angry old man.

Things like physical appearance, speech patterns, demeanor, etc. matter to more voters more than the substance it often seems.

The real war is going to be a media one, but Obama has been able to hold his own with it pretty well so far. Media wars can also be counteracted pretty effectively by a good ground game, and his has been outstanding.

There's plenty to feel good about, but there is still a lot of work to do to make sure good word about Obama gets out there, and we dispel the Republican myths.

Send this Article to a Friend



Separate multiple emails with a comma (,); limit 5 recipients






Your email has been sent successfully!

Manage this Video in Your Playlists




notify when someone comments
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
  
Learn More