Neil deGrasse Tyson talks about the Enterprise

YouTube description: Every Comic-Con ends with one of the event's most popular panels, the Starship Smackdown, in which 12 spacecraft battle it out for sole supremacy (based not on armament or shielding, but, usually, whose captain is best with the ladies). This year, it came down to--astonishingly and agonizingly--the USS Enterprise NCC-1701 (1960's television series) vs. the USS Enterprise NCC-1701-A refit (original motion pictures). Enjoying his first Comic-Con appearance, astrophysicist Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson stood to offer his comic perspective on which of the two very worthy vessels should win the day. The hall, and ultimately the panel of judges, agreed.
RadHazGsays...

His point was that before this ship, everything was simplistic, boring and ultimately, unimaginative. To the people first seeing the original Enterprise starship it was truly incredible because they had never before seen something like it. No audience afterwards could have quite the same reaction because now that the ship existed, nothing else could reach quite the same level because all others afterwards were derivative of the original. Something along those lines anyway. >> ^doogle:

what's his point here? It's a beautiful ship because what came before it was some sort of saucer from the <garble mumble> movie?

Paybacksays...

>> ^doogle:

what's his point here? It's a beautiful ship because what came before it was some sort of saucer from the <garble mumble> movie?


The original "The Day the Earth Stood Still". The silver-undies-wearing guy he refers to would probably be Gort. I think his point would be NCC-1701 is a "revolutionary" step from previous "space ships" as opposed to NCC-1701-A, which is an "evolutionary" step. Sorta the 1964 1/2 Mustang compared to the 1968/69.

chingalerasays...

>> ^Payback:

>> ^doogle:
what's his point here? It's a beautiful ship because what came before it was some sort of saucer from the <garble mumble> movie?

The original "The Day the Earth Stood Still". The silver-undies-wearing guy he refers to would probably be Gort. I think his point would be NCC-1701 is a "revolutionary" step from previous "space ships" as opposed to NCC-1701-A, which is an "evolutionary" step. Sorta the 1964 1/2 Mustang compared to the 1968/69.


KLAATU....BARADA....NIKTO!!!

DarkenRahlsays...

If we all sat around watching you playing at your hobbies in your off time, we'd likely ask the same thing about your chosen profession, and likely be much more bored having watched what you consider hobbies...>> ^bmacs27:

Does he ever... like... do science?

bmacs27says...

>> ^DarkenRahl:

If we all sat around watching you playing at your hobbies in your off time, we'd likely ask the same thing about your chosen profession, and likely be much more bored having watched what you consider hobbies...>> ^bmacs27:
Does he ever... like... do science?



Seriously though, does he have any real scientific credentials? That is, is he more Feynman or more Hawking?

rottenseedsays...

He's probably promoted from research to educator of the masses. He doesn't have to spend years in a lab collecting/analyzing data to find out the total mass of the universe and such. He just has to stay current on findings and report them to us in a way the lowest common denominator can understand...>> ^bmacs27:

Does he ever... like... do science?

Fletchsays...

You are absolutely right, NDT. Of course the original Enterprise is the greatest starship of all time. You'd have to be daft not to know that. Now sit down and shut up, attention whore!

Truckchasesays...

>> ^bmacs27:

>> ^DarkenRahl:
If we all sat around watching you playing at your hobbies in your off time, we'd likely ask the same thing about your chosen profession, and likely be much more bored having watched what you consider hobbies...>> ^bmacs27:
Does he ever... like... do science?


Seriously though, does he have any real scientific credentials? That is, is he more Feynman or more Hawking?

Ask Pluto.

budzossays...

>> ^mxxcon:

Hell no!
NCC-1701-D is better!


Someone on AICN said the other day that the Enterprise D is one of the most cocaine-fuelled designs* ever. He said the entire thing looks like a giant porn set.

*interior

mxxconsays...

>> ^budzos:

>> ^mxxcon:
Hell no!
NCC-1701-D is better!

Someone on AICN said the other day that the Enterprise D is one of the most cocaine-fuelled designs ever. He said the entire thing looks like a giant porn set.
interior
don't care. it's still better.

budzossays...

Why don't you just stamp I LOVE COCAINE on your forehead?

>> ^mxxcon:

>> ^budzos:
>> ^mxxcon:
Hell no!
NCC-1701-D is better!

Someone on AICN said the other day that the Enterprise D is one of the most cocaine-fuelled designs ever. He said the entire thing looks like a giant porn set.
interior
don't care. it's still better.

mxxconsays...

>> ^budzos:

Why don't you just stamp I LOVE COCAINE on your forehead?
>> ^mxxcon:
>> ^budzos:
>> ^mxxcon:
Hell no!
NCC-1701-D is better!

Someone on AICN said the other day that the Enterprise D is one of the most cocaine-fuelled designs ever. He said the entire thing looks like a giant porn set.
interior
don't care. it's still better.

Why would I put a stamp on top of the same tatoo?

Send this Article to a Friend



Separate multiple emails with a comma (,); limit 5 recipients






Your email has been sent successfully!

Manage this Video in Your Playlists




notify when someone comments
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
  
Learn More