Audience Member Nails Deepak Chopra

Audience member zings Deepak during an open mic question period.
VoodooVsays...

<sarcasm>
Just another case of the "gotcha journalism" at work here. Why won't they just leave Deepak alone!
</sarcasm>

I'll give the guy credit, that was an awesome zinger, but that's all it was, a zinger. Deepak obviously could have phrased his statement better because I'm assuming he meant belief in terms of dogmatic religion.

The sad part is that the guy probably thinks he totally demolished his entire argument when he really just got a nice play on words in.

gharksays...

>> ^VoodooV:

<sarcasm>
Just another case of the "gotcha journalism" at work here. Why won't they just leave Deepak alone!
</sarcasm>
I'll give the guy credit, that was an awesome zinger, but that's all it was, a zinger. Deepak obviously could have phrased his statement better because I'm assuming he meant belief in terms of dogmatic religion.
The sad part is that the guy probably thinks he totally demolished his entire argument when he really just got a nice play on words in.


Yea agreed, it didn't really undercut anything other than the wording.

garmachisays...

I actually don't think the audience member was trying to prove or disprove anything, I think he was trying to be silly. This is like asking if God could create a rock so heavy that even he couldn't lift it. A meaningless silly question formed only to spark debate, as is presupposes the existence of a god at all.

ponceleonsays...

>> ^VoodooV:

<sarcasm>
Just another case of the "gotcha journalism" at work here. Why won't they just leave Deepak alone!
</sarcasm>
I'll give the guy credit, that was an awesome zinger, but that's all it was, a zinger. Deepak obviously could have phrased his statement better because I'm assuming he meant belief in terms of dogmatic religion.
The sad part is that the guy probably thinks he totally demolished his entire argument when he really just got a nice play on words in.


Exactly, this has the intellectual weight of a "douchebagsayswhat" joke.

rebuildersays...

>> ^garmachi:

I actually don't think the audience member was trying to prove or disprove anything, I think he was trying to be silly. This is like asking if God could create a rock so heavy that even he couldn't lift it. A meaningless silly question formed only to spark debate, as is presupposes the existence of a god at all.


Actually I think that's a very valid question as it illustrates that belief in an omnipotent being results in logical contradictions, or at the very least that such belief is not something it makes much sense to try to rationally discuss.

bcglorfsays...

The sad part is that the guy probably thinks he totally demolished his entire argument when he really just got a nice play on words in.

Deepak's argument was "all belief is a cover up for insecurity". If he doesn't really mean ALL belief, his argument is really just a nice play on words. So, I would say the speaker really did demolish the entire argument, since the entire argument was nothing more than a play on words itself.

kronosposeidonsays...

Exactly. Deepak's argument is nothing more than a sound bite based on a flimsy premise. I think this guy exposed exactly how flimsy Chopra's premise is. Deepak should have worded his argument more carefully. It may not be as catchy and compact as his original argument, but hey, neither are life's complexities. Let him defend himself; don't do the job for him.

Why does anyone here want to give this 'new age' spirituality and alternative medicine pusher the benefit of the doubt anyway? Screw him. >> ^bcglorf:

The sad part is that the guy probably thinks he totally demolished his entire argument when he really just got a nice play on words in.
Deepak's argument was "all belief is a cover up for insecurity". If he doesn't really mean ALL belief, his argument is really just a nice play on words. So, I would say the speaker really did demolish the entire argument, since the entire argument was nothing more than a play on words itself.

Discuss...

🗨️ Emojis & HTML

Enable JavaScript to submit a comment.

Possible *Invocations
discarddeadnotdeaddiscussfindthumbqualitybrieflongnsfwblockednochannelbandupeoflengthpromotedoublepromote

Send this Article to a Friend



Separate multiple emails with a comma (,); limit 5 recipients






Your email has been sent successfully!

Manage this Video in Your Playlists




notify when someone comments
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
  
Learn More