Woman photoshopped in different countries - What is Beauty?

YT: Do the standards of beauty differ across cultures or are they universal? To find out, Kansas City-based journalist Esther Honig sent an unaltered picture of herself to Photoshop experts in more than 25 countries and asked them to, "make me beautiful." Her illuminating project, entitled "Before & After," dramatically illustrates how ideals of beauty vary from culture to culture.


See more at Esthers blog http://www.estherhonig.com/#!before--after-/cvkn
RunRabbitRunsays...

That be charging money for doing no work approach. Nice.

I wish they'd actually asked people in various countries which portrait they prefer (with the countries hidden). To see if it's a cultural taste, or just shit photoshop work.

entr0pysays...

Yeah, I do think it's just a random smattering of the Photoshoppery you can expect from mechanical turk and fiver, and can't be taken to express the standards of the culture.

. . . But, that was fun, and a great idea. It would be interesting to see how genuine experts working in fashion magazines or advertizing around the world would approach it.

But of course, none of those are better than just her. No need to cover her up with pixels.

Paybacksays...

Interesting that Serbia made her eyes bigger, but everyone else either left them or made smaller.

Looks like a couple of them just sent back the original with a bit of digital "concealer".

Ickstersays...

I believe it was an experiment to see what alterations people in other cultures would perform to "make her beautiful", not an attempt to get people to give her a photo that made her feel better about herself. Obviously, there were differences, but I think the lack of skill on the part of the photo editors kind of washed them out.

Paybacksaid:

I also gotta say, she must have self esteem issues if she thinks anyone would need to do much to "make her" beautiful.

Paybacksays...

I was objecting to the nomenclature. I realize the intent.

Ickstersaid:

I believe it was an experiment to see what alterations people in other cultures would perform to "make her beautiful", not an attempt to get people to give her a photo that made her feel better about herself. Obviously, there were differences, but I think the lack of skill on the part of the photo editors kind of washed them out.

luxury_piesays...

Those "experts" sure use a lot of blur.

And whatever the guy in Germany was on, no we don't like our women looking like fresh out of the morgue. I would have send the photo back unedited btw.

Jinxsays...

Likewise, but I'd insist that I had spent days making subtle changes to enhance her natural beauty. Then it would be my experiment to see if you can convince somebody that a placebo unedited picture of themselves is more beautiful than an unedited picture of themselves.

ps. A few tried to even up her eyes but they ended up making her look uglier... asymmetry ftw.

luxury_piesaid:

Those "experts" sure use a lot of blur.

And whatever the guy in Germany was on, no we don't like our women looking like fresh out of the morgue. I would have send the photo back unedited btw.

siftbotsays...

This video has been declared non-functional; embed code must be fixed within 2 days or it will be sent to the dead pool - declared dead by Norsuelefantti.

Send this Article to a Friend



Separate multiple emails with a comma (,); limit 5 recipients






Your email has been sent successfully!

Manage this Video in Your Playlists




notify when someone comments
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
  
Learn More