Possibly First Ever Video of Peacock Spider Mating Behavior

Footage of the courtship and mating behaviour of the Australian Peacock spider by Dr Jurgen Otto.

More information can be founda ABC Catalyst.
mxxconsays...

>> ^Friesian:

That has to be some of the worst editing and voiceover work I've seen. Shame though, because the spiders were pretty cool subject matter.


at least it's not bastardized with idiotic special effects or cutesy music.
this is a perfect example that nature is awesome enough as it is that it doesn't need any fancy narratives or fake sound effects or artificial setups the way they do it on Planet Earth or Blue Oceans.

major kudos to this guy for keeping it natural.

Friesiansays...

>> ^grinter:

>> ^Friesian:
That has to be some of the worst editing and voiceover work I've seen. Shame though, because the spiders were pretty cool subject matter.

If biologist were paid what BBC producers were, then maybe it would make sense that you are complaining. As it is, I think this video is a pretty good value.
If you want cheesy, polished narration, check out the ABC version:
http://www.abc.net.au/catalyst/stories/3160792.htm


I never said I wanted cheesy, polished narration. Nor do I expect high quality swooping shots of glorious vistas, all edited together in a magical and breathtaking piece of art.

However, I would have liked something which didn't have varying background sound levels (it could easily have been muted or evened out during the closeups with voiceover). I would have also liked less shots of the same thing. "This female is watching carefully", followed by "And this one as well", followed by a third "Another female arrives on the scene", followed by 20 seconds of random shots of the females. There was no context to those shots - they could have been stock footage of unconnected females that was added into the film solely to pad it out. They didn't add anything to the purpose of the film, which was showcasing the mating behaviour, and they didn't really tie into the overall direction of the narration.

The video is indeed pretty good value, but I think it's a shame that there are several small things that could be improved without having to be ABC and without a massive time/money investment. No idea if I'm the only one, but while the content was very interesting I did not watch the whole 6.5 minute clip, which to me is indicative of the mistakes I mentioned.

TheSluiceGatesays...

Yeah that "let's make a narrative out of random unrelated clips" thing really pisses me off. I thought they'd stopped doing that by the 1990s.

That said, this footage is incredible, especially due to the size of the spiders involved only being a few milimeters.

Friesiansays...

>> ^mxxcon:

>> ^Friesian:
That has to be some of the worst editing and voiceover work I've seen. Shame though, because the spiders were pretty cool subject matter.

at least it's not bastardized with idiotic special effects or cutesy music.
this is a perfect example that nature is awesome enough as it is that it doesn't need any fancy narratives or fake sound effects or artificial setups the way they do it on Planet Earth or Blue Oceans.
major kudos to this guy for keeping it natural.


Oh, I totally agree that it's a good thing it's not bastardised with idiotic special effects or cutesy music. However, I would disagree that he's keeping it natural. It's clearly been edited (which I have no problem with), but the edited-in narration is, in my opinion, anything but natural.

The beginning of the clip is just fine, with him talking away. It was when it got to the narration part that it irked me somewhat.

Don't get me wrong - this is indeed amazing footage, especially, as @TheSluiceGate said, considering the size of the spiders. Major kudos to Jürgen for capturing it.

Send this Article to a Friend



Separate multiple emails with a comma (,); limit 5 recipients






Your email has been sent successfully!

Manage this Video in Your Playlists




notify when someone comments
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
  
Learn More