Admins please settle a discard dispute?

Early Rottenseed and I discarded what we both saw as dupes. One posted first, but the other published first.

Which gets to stay? Oh, we asked it to come to siftalk w/ *discuss. Didn't see it. Is there another place it's to go for discussing?

The sifts in question:
http://www.videosift.com/video/Bill-O-Reilly-Goes-Nuts
http://www.videosift.com/video/Complete-ORielly-Meltdown
theaceofclubz says...

Ummm, so I'm not really sure what occurred here. I posted my video at 1 am(Central US) last night, which is reflected by the post date on the discarded post(I guess published dates aren't shown on discarded posts). If you ask me I'm pretty sure I posted first, if someone wants to second and return it that's fine with me.

lucky760 says...

Well, I'm no Dag, but the rule is whatever is submitted first is the original. Published, not published... Those make no difference because if one was posted when the other was already on the Sift, it was a duplicate submission, plain and simple.

theaceofclubz says...

Alright well, I'm returning mine. My post time is first.
"Complete O'Rielly Meltdown [mine]
posted by theaceofclubz 18 hours 53 minutes 43 seconds ago • 239 views"
versus
"Bill O Reilly Goes Nuts
posted by sepatown 11 hours 49 minutes 8 seconds ago • 218 views"
and
"Bill O'Reilly Goes absolutely Nuts!
posted by eric3579 9 hours 27 minutes 55 seconds ago • 208 views"

also the first comment on my submission was by Fedquip 16 hrs. ago vs
first comments on the other ones at 10 hrs. and 5 hrs ago respectively.

Send this Article to a Friend



Separate multiple emails with a comma (,); limit 5 recipients






Your email has been sent successfully!

Manage this Video in Your Playlists

New Blog Posts from All Members