Misconceptions About the Universe - Veritasium

Derek discusses how the universe is expanding faster than the speed of light. My brain hurts.
siftbotsays...

Self promoting this video and sending it back into the queue for one more try; last queued Thursday, May 29th, 2014 2:32am PDT - promote requested by original submitter nanrod.

mxxconsays...

I question accuracy of this video...If it's not wrong, it's gotta be extremely oversimplifying or misrepresenting some aspects of what's covered there...

eric3579says...

Veritasium youtube comment:
Some people have been sending wikipedia references saying parts of this video are wrong, but I think it's wikipedia with the misconceptions. For further reference check out this paper: http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=8838887

mxxconsaid:

I question accuracy of this video...If it's not wrong, it's gotta be extremely oversimplifying or misrepresenting some aspects of what's covered there...

dannym3141says...

It is simplified.

Some of the concepts are actually pretty hard to put into words and just are how they are. And for each cosmologist you speak to you will encounter a different opinion of the standard cosmological model or parts of its construction.

There are parts of it i don't like because i can't follow and feel comfortable with each step. The maths makes sense, but there's nothing logical and connected in my understanding. At first i didn't like that, but then i realised that we all accept quantum mechanics where charged particles accelerate without radiating, and "instantaneously" move between distinct energy levels.......

In other words, every physical law we've got is just our primitive way of understanding the signals sent from our senses to our brain. Things seem to make sense to us the more experience we have with it happening. We don't understand why matter moves towards other matter via "gravity" - a word which we accept and go 'ahhh gravity - i understand now' but why the hell should it and/or why should it exist in the first place merely to move towards one another?!

So gravity attracts things (why?!) and time only runs in one direction (why!?) and energy is quantized according to the planck constant (WHY!?) and ... the universe is more or less like it's shown in the video! But why why why!? Well, that's a question for a philosopher.

mxxconsaid:

I question accuracy of this video...If it's not wrong, it's gotta be extremely oversimplifying or misrepresenting some aspects of what's covered there...

Ickstersays...

This is a great illustration of how I feel every time I try to wrap my head around this stuff; to really understand it, you somehow need to keep in mind everything you know, while rejecting the "obvious" conclusions you draw from that knowledge because you have to be open to the new knowledge you're going to insert that causes you to adjust the knowledge you already had.

It's always astonishing to me that there are enough people on this planet with the necessary mental flexibility to keep pushing the boundaries of our understanding of the universe, because I can just barely understand so many of the things they've figured out.

dannym3141said:

It is simplified.

Some of the concepts are actually pretty hard to put into words and just are how they are. And for each cosmologist you speak to you will encounter a different opinion of the standard cosmological model or parts of its construction.

There are parts of it i don't like because i can't follow and feel comfortable with each step. The maths makes sense, but there's nothing logical and connected in my understanding. At first i didn't like that, but then i realised that we all accept quantum mechanics where charged particles accelerate without radiating, and "instantaneously" move between distinct energy levels.......

In other words, every physical law we've got is just our primitive way of understanding the signals sent from our senses to our brain. Things seem to make sense to us the more experience we have with it happening. We don't understand why matter moves towards other matter via "gravity" - a word which we accept and go 'ahhh gravity - i understand now' but why the hell should it and/or why should it exist in the first place merely to move towards one another?!

So gravity attracts things (why?!) and time only runs in one direction (why!?) and energy is quantized according to the planck constant (WHY!?) and ... the universe is more or less like it's shown in the video! But why why why!? Well, that's a question for a philosopher.

TheFreakjokingly says...

It's controversial in the scientific community and the views of the dissenters are being silenced.
This video is full of obvious lies perpetrated by the majority Liberal Scientific Elite for financial gain.
People only accept on faith what these cosmologists say because Science is their religion.

Wake up sheeple. Corporate America will lead you to the light if you will stop resisting the obvious truth.
THE UNIVERSE ISN'T INFINITE AND EXPANDING...BIG MACS ARE DELICIOUS!!!!

mxxconsaid:

I question accuracy of this video...If it's not wrong, it's gotta be extremely oversimplifying or misrepresenting some aspects of what's covered there...

siftbotsays...

Tags for this video have been changed from 'veritasium, space, universe, lightspeed, observable, hubble, derek, muller' to 'veritasium, space, universe, lightspeed, observable, hubble, derek muller' - edited by xxovercastxx

Send this Article to a Friend



Separate multiple emails with a comma (,); limit 5 recipients






Your email has been sent successfully!

Manage this Video in Your Playlists




notify when someone comments
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
  
Learn More