*discuss -- snuff?

This video is being sent to Sift Talk for discussion - discuss requested by nibiyabi.

Snuff. *kill

You could make the argument that this is to put Schindler's list into a real context, but I dunno. I vote keep.

I dunno, it shows how you shouldn't believe everything in movies, as there are more inaccuracies in Shinder's List. This is historical and isn't that gruesome. I guess you'd have to discard alot of war docus along with this since they all show the deaths of thousands of people.

From the guidelines:

Note: The presence of human fatality is acceptable and not considered "snuff" if presented as a limited portion of a lengthy educational, informative news report or documentary. Our definition of "snuff" does include but is not exclusive to any short clip in which a human fatality occurs whether or not any victims are actually visible on camera.

Seems to apply here.

Seeing as his death was more strangulation than severing of the spinal cord, I wouldn't even call this snuff. He clearly hasn't died by the time the video ends. Plus it is educational and not exploitative. I vote keep it.

I'd say this is ready to *return

Returning this video from Sift Talk - return requested by rasch187.

aaaaand *promote

Self promoting this video and sending it back into the queue for one more try; last queued Wednesday, December 3rd, 2008 1:18pm PST - promote requested by original submitter rasch187.

It's historical. Sure, it's rather disgusting, but it's not snuff.

Short drop.

third time's the charm

Fuck that Nazi.

totally NOT what I want to find on the sift.. rare downvote

Then don't watch it?

Interesting that they had to try it 3 times.

Death penalty is unethical, even for nazis.

>> ^Sarzy:
From the guidelines:
Note: The presence of human fatality is acceptable and not considered "snuff" if presented as a limited portion of a lengthy educational, informative news report or documentary. Our definition of "snuff" does include but is not exclusive to any short clip in which a human fatality occurs whether or not any victims are actually visible on camera.
Seems to apply here.


I know the discussion is over, but I can't help wondering how the boldface text could possibly apply to this video. It consists of two short clips of someone being killed (albeit one is theatrical). The human fatalities are not presented as a limited part of any kind of lengthy news report or documentary.

Hey they forgot to shoot him in the balls first.

The thumbnail image for this video has been updated - thumbnail added by critical_d.