Not yet a member? No problem!
Sign-up just takes a second.
Forgot your password?
Recover it now.
Already signed up?
Log in now.
Forgot your password?
Recover it now.
Not yet a member? No problem!
Sign-up just takes a second.
Remember your password?
Log in now.
12 Comments
Praetorsays...An old wound in my heart has finally scabbed over.
Kofisays...... in a fire
MilkmanDansays...Full story on this? That looked like a real deleted scene, but if it was that would suggest that there was a pretty major script rewrite after filming that bit.
The best explanation I can muster is that it was largely a real deleted scene, but that Jar-Jar actually jumped out in the real version, and this is a fan-made edit that cut out that escape and/or CGI'ed him back into the vehicle as it went over the brink. Or I guess possibly it is all real and they were going to have him meet up with the group again later after miraculous surviving the fall -- gungan reflexes or something (hey, the film has midichlorians, so why the hell not).
If it is a fan-edit, they did one hell of a job, and started from footage I've never seen.
---
EDIT:
I googled around and came up empty. This video and blurbs about it are making the internet rounds, but nobody seems to say anything other than that it is a deleted scene and it was probably cut for "creating too many plot holes"...
That seems like a pretty huge understatement to me. Ignoring the fact that Jar-Jar appears (briefly) in Eps 2 and 3, he plays a pretty major role with a lot of screen time in the Gungans vs Droids portion of the final 3-way battle sequence at the end, which happens well after where this scene would appear in the movie (right?).
Plus, Ep. 1 is very clearly a kids movie, and it would be pretty dark to kill off your comic relief / slapstick character halfway through the movie.
Maybe they had some early warning from focus groups that Jar-Jar was going to be ... not exactly well received and decided to film this just as a joke or even to play it for those focus groups and see their reactions?
Very weird. Not that I mind seeing Jar-Jar die, but I'm quite puzzled by this!
antjokingly says...Bravo!
Orzjokingly says...Why is this not #1?!?
ChaosEnginesays...@MilkmanDan, as one of the only people on the planet to own the Ep.1 DVD (hey I was hoping it might get better somehow), I can confirm that you're pretty much spot on. It is a real deleted scene, but unfortunately jar jar wasn't brutally murdered in it
MilkmanDansays...Thanks --
Which guess was I close with?
A) Over the falls but didn't die, or
B) Jumped clear before the vehicle goes over?
I'll assume A since B would make this edited from the original deleted scene, and therefore not "real"?
Again, thanks for the info -- especially since it required you to make the shameful admission of owning the DVD!
(just kidding, I bought it also for the sake of completeness but my copy is on the opposite side of the planet since I didn't bring DVDs with me to Thailand -- don't recall ever watching the special features / deleted scenes)
@MilkmanDan, as one of the only people on the planet to own the Ep.1 DVD (hey I was hoping it might get better somehow), I can confirm that you're pretty much spot on. It is a real deleted scene, but unfortunately jar jar wasn't brutally murdered in it
ChaosEnginesays...From memory I think it was B.
And funnily enough my copy is also on the other side of the world
Thanks --
Which guess was I close with?
A) Over the falls but didn't die, or
B) Jumped clear before the vehicle goes over?
I'll assume A since B would make this edited from the original deleted scene, and therefore not "real"?
Again, thanks for the info -- especially since it required you to make the shameful admission of owning the DVD!
(just kidding, I bought it also for the sake of completeness but my copy is on the opposite side of the planet since I didn't bring DVDs with me to Thailand -- don't recall ever watching the special features / deleted scenes)
breaddoughrisingsays...I swear to whatever is swearable upon, when I saw this movie in the theater at Arizona Mills mall, there was a waterfall scene like this with grappling hook and all, but Jar-Jar did NOT go over the edge.
Zawashsays...I want a *happy and *dark for this.
*wipes tear from eye*
siftbotsays...Invocations (dark, happy) cannot be called by Zawash because Zawash is not privileged - sorry.
Wookiesticksays...I prefer him frozen in carbonite.
But as most people guessed, this is an actual deleted scene from the Episode 1 DVD. The actual scene shows Jar Jar swimming away with powerful Gungan swimming skills. The original poster just edited the scene of Jar-Jar swimming away, and dubbed him screaming over the existing audio track of the vehicle plummeting over the waterfall. Notice the ride is empty as it falls?
Discuss...
Enable JavaScript to submit a comment.