[yt] Collision is a documentary film released on October 27, 2009 featuring a debate between prominent atheist Christopher Hitchens and Douglas Wilson, Presbyterian pastor of Christ Church Moscow. Described by Hitchens as a "buddy-and-road" movie, it provides an overview of several days worth of debates following the release of their book Is Christianity Good for the World? The book was generated by correspondence published in Christianity Today.
The partnership between Hitchens and Wilson began in 2007, when Hitchens invited anyone to debate his viewpoints following the release of his book God is not Great. Wilson's agent heard the offer and put him in touch with Hitchens, leading to a series of written debates published in Christianity Today, which eventually were compiled into Is Christianity Good for the World? Filmmaker Darren Doane heard about the exchanges between the two and sought them out to make a film. The film was featured on CNN, Fox News; NPR; The Laura Ingraham Show and others.
After the men finally met in person while shooting the film, both got along well, despite the heated exchanges, in part from a shared appreciation for P.G. Wodehouse.
Hitchens said in Slate Magazine that "I haven't yet run into an argument that has made me want to change my mind... However, I have discovered that the so-called Christian right is much less monolithic, and very much more polite and hospitable, than I would once have thought, or than most liberals believe."
Darren Doane, the filmmaker, said: "These guys ended up at the bar laughing, joking, drinking. There were so many things that they had in common...Opinions on history and politics. Literature and poetry. They agreed on so many things. Except on the existence of God."
Wilson argued that atheists could be good people, could share Christian values and Christians could repudiate many things atheists also repudiated: yet Wilson argued that atheists could not argue for an objective moral standard but could affirm a standard, if it happened to exist, that of "eat, drink and be merry for tomorrow maybe we die", but no other.
10 Comments
A10anisMan, I miss Hitch..
siftbotMoving this video to kulpims's personal queue. It failed to receive enough votes to get sifted up to the front page within 2 days.
lampishthingSomeone should * promote this. In the meantime I shall *quality.
siftbotBoosting this quality contribution up in the Hot Listing - declared quality by lampishthing.
Trancecoach*promote
siftbotPromoting this video back to the front page; last published Thursday, August 16th, 2012 9:10am PDT - promote requested by Trancecoach.
Jinxsays...Good shit.
A lot of this comes down to the origin of morality. They spend most of the video debating this, I don't think Douglas really made a very good case but did well to hitch (hurrhurr) the entire debate on it quite so much. "Your religion poisons everything" "Our religion enables you to make that determination" ad infinitum. Eventually he drags up Stalin which may as well be the religious equivalant of reductio ad hitlerium. Would have it been better if Stalin had anticipated judgement for his actions? Probably, but would he have just used what ever religious conviction he held to justify his genocide? Probably. Are mass murders only evil when commited by atheists because those commited by the religious are mandated by God?
And yah. I miss Hitch. It was very kind of him to write indeed.
DrewNumberTwosays...It's pretty silly to suggest that no one was moral before Jesus was about 30 years old.
Edgeman2112For the love of god, hold..the..camera..STILL.
messengerThat's the best challenge I've ever seen Hitch face. Too bad the editing cut off his responses. Even if they were just staring into space for a few seconds, or conceding the point, I would like to know that Hitch actually took a punch and felt it.
Discuss...
Enable JavaScript to submit a comment.