Mesh Networking and Global Warming

TED 2007: Robin Chase on Getting Cars Off The Road has some powerful ideas.. you should vote for it. Robin Chase is the founder of ZipCar, a ride sharing service. She lays out a cogent plan for reducing CO2 emissions and car use - coming to a suprising conclusion.

 Ethan Zuckerman has done a fantastic job of capturing her talk, which I'll quote wholesale here--

Robin Chase - Sharing Cars and Networks


Robin Chase is the inventor of Zipcar, a business that’s commercialized the social behavior of carsharing. Her focus is market-based pricing of transportation and the ways that wireless technologies could transform the transport sector.

Fuel efficient cars, she tells us, are not enough. Even if we had massive conversion to fuel efficient cars, we’d see only a 4% reduction in energy usage. We need behavioral changes as well. By making vehicles available in large cities and offering users a selection of vehicles, this gives consumers “all of the good stuff and none of the bad”, like the costs of vehicle maintenance.

The 100,000 members of Zipcar share 3,000 cars. They average only 500 miles a year of driving, far less than other urban car users. Users seem to like it - the userbase has doubled every year. But the pricing keeps use of vehicles down - at $8-10 an hour or $65 a day, are you willing to rent a car to go buy some ice cream?

To make this system work, it has to be technologically trivial, both to make it useful to the customer and to keep up margins. She’s now working on another technically lightweight solution to ridesharing, called Goloco. She mentions that ridesharing has excellent social benefits - if you travel to TED with someone, you generate social capital as well as saving fuel.

She points out that car travel is underpriced and overconsumed. To change this, we’re going to need financial incentives and disincentives. Ken Livingston introduced congestion charges in Central London - evidently this was popular, since Livingston got re-elected. She tells us that congestion charges are a precursor to road pricing - we currently tax road use by fuel taxes. But as fuel costs drop, this won’t work in the long term.

Introducing road pricing is going to require real technical innovation in wireless networks. She invokes The Graduate and gives us the one word of business advice: “Adhoc peer-to-peer self-configuring wireless networks” - in other words, mesh networks. She points out that One Laptop Per Child incorporates mesh and that mesh networks helped in the recovery of New Orleans.

Chase’s big idea is mesh networks based on automobiles, where there’s a device in every car in America to support congestion pricing and road tolls. She suggests that this could be a revolution in providing free and open networks supporting a wide range of applications but worries that, because there are no ongoing revenues from mesh and no one lobbying for mesh at the federal level. (I’d strongly disagree with this, pointing to projects like CuWin, and challenging whether this strategy can work outside of urban areas, but it’s certainly an intriguing thought.)

 

fissionchips says...

I watched the talk and appreciated the rundown on Zipcar, but without any background information Robin Chase's call for road tolls was a huge stretch.

I see no way in which road tolls are a critical app for mesh networks. Cars tapping into a citywide wireless internet? Sure, but not the other way around.

Many problems spring to mind:
1) People don't want to have their location monitored at all times.
2) You don't need WiMax speeds to handle payment data.
3) Try getting the public, politicians, and automakers to agree on this. Get back to me in 25 years.
4) Who wants wireless internet if it's powered by innefficient gasoline engines?
5) The idea of taking a public good (like roads) and converting it into a private good (by way of road taxes) could have a huge effect on where new roads are built and whether old roads are maintained.

I'll end my rant with an unrelated but valuable article:
My Other Car is a Bright Green City

aaronfr says...

reposting my comment from the video:

wow! she was a horrible speaker, i thought TED people usually did better on stage than that.

but that is beside the point. i agree that they are innovative solutions to some of our problems, but the chances of any of them going into effect are laughable. maybe the zip car and loco thing because people still have some kind of a choice in those situations. but the grand scheme: instantly begin taxing everyone for every mile they drive while simultaneously raising gas prices in order to limit the amount of choice that they have by imposing further congestion taxes and installing some geek-love communications network that will further enhance the efficiency of this repressive system. yeah thats what i want for my future.

i don't even own a car, haven't for a few years. i think US gas prices are way too low to begin with because they externalize the costs of fuel. i even think we are going to have to make some difficult and sometimes painful choices in order to correct the problem of global climate change. but her scheme is just scary and oppressive.

Send this Article to a Friend



Separate multiple emails with a comma (,); limit 5 recipients






Your email has been sent successfully!

Manage this Video in Your Playlists

New Blog Posts from All Members