The thumbnail image for this video has been updated - thumbnail added by eric3579.

Makes no sense. I call bullshit. He doesn't first say what to color which if he did i might buy it. He just said pick up a random color then he says what to color. How is she not a plant. Anyone? Or is this him doing amazing magic by knowing what she would pick up even though he did the animals in order. Am i missing something?

I agree, there's clearly a missing piece. She didn't pick the colors by the order they were presented to her (in which case silver would have been 2nd), and he made no mention of other cues which would have lead to her selecting them in that order. Maybe it was simply top to bottom, other than the horse being first due to cobalt being shoved in her face. He does have a big honkin' earpiece in though, which would have made it easy for someone to feed him her marker selections. Occams razor: is it more likely that he was being fed her selections and telling her which animals to color accordingly, or that some subtle unknown cue caused her to pick the marker order she did? The subtle imagery clues he referenced (Katy's amber owl mug for example) appear to me to be total red herrings, as he told her the animal after she selected the color.

Moving this video to jimnms's personal queue. It failed to receive enough votes to get sifted up to the front page within 2 days.