I love this performance. Oh, and if you go to youtube and look at the comments on this video, you'll get a nice example of what was parodied here on the other vid a few days ago: lots of people who probably can't even play cello critiquing this guy's interpretation.

What a coincidence, I was just listening to Bach's Harpsichord concerto

Upvote. I swear, I am becoming a cellophile if there is such a word.

One moment, I will google it.
Nope, nothing. Someone should make it a word.

Tofumar - why does one have to be able to play music to appreciate or comment on it?

*bravo

Adding video to channels (Bravo) - requested by Deano.

*promote

Promoting this video back to the front page; last published Friday, June 29th, 2007 8:35pm PDT - promote requested by Deano.

>> ^Tofumar:
I love this performance. Oh, and if you go to youtube and look at the comments on this video, you'll get a nice example of what was parodied here on the other vid a few days ago: lots of people who probably can't even play cello critiquing this guy's interpretation.

lol you don't have to play a particular instrument to criticize a performance played on it, as long as you're not criticizing his technique but his interpretation. I do not like this guy's interpretation, it feels too fiddly, too fast, he emphasizes notes in weird places and he speeds up/slows down too fast and too much at once. But on the other hand, I love Phoebe Carrai's interpretation. Whatever if this Maisky is celebrated and won prizes, I don't care. Carrai's interpretation is better to my ear that his (she played for 10 years with a german historical ensemble devoted to 17th and 18th century music and it shows).