Fighting back against anti-choice language

This is an excellent ad produced by the National Advocates of Pregnant Women (NAPW) that takes on all those who describe abortion as "murder," "genocide," "holocaust," etc. NAPW's executive director Lynn Paltrow wrote in the Huffington Post:

"[W]hen individuals and organizations use this language -- "violence," "torture," "an attack on innocent life," "executing a child," "killing," "baby-killing," "murder," "child murder," "mass murder," "like slavery," "genocide," "holocaust," "worse than any holocaust" -- they are not just describing a procedure or the small number of doctors who provide women with abortion services. They are also talking about the millions of pregnant women who have had and will continue to have abortions, whether or not there are any doctors left alive to provide them safely.

Who are the millions of "murderous" women who have abortions? Sixty-one percent of women having abortions are already mothers. By the age of 45, 84% of all women in U.S. will have become pregnant and given birth and 43% will have had an abortion.

In other words, the women who have abortions are overwhelmingly mothers.

So we need to ask -- do the people who use this language really think the mothers who have had abortions are the same as, or worse than, those who carry out torture, kill children, and commit mass-murder?"
quantumushroomsays...

For a woman in a First World country to resort to an abortion with so many birth control methods available is the apex of ignorance.

You can CHOOSE to call "partial birth abortion" murder or infanticide, both terms are correct.

rottenseedsays...

^So you are aware that contraception is not 100%? And you are aware that despite there being a multitude of forms of contraception out there, people still make mistakes? You are aware that sometimes having a baby when you make a mistake ISN'T the best option right?

That's what I don't get about you fucking neo-con dumbshits. You don't want our government to provide planned parenting clinics where one can be educated and get free contraception, yet you scream about having to pay for welfare...and on top of it all, you don't believe in abortion?! I know neocons are generally uptight, loveless, sexless, prostitute purchasing old guys, but some people actually get laid and in the heat of the moment have unprotected sex and still don't want to have a 1st, 2nd or 3rd child

Either you're all very delusional about the human condition or just generally retarded.

dgandhisays...

While I agree with the intent, this seems like rather ineffectual rhetoric to me. The fact that 40% of the population are mothers, and most of them have had an abortion, does no do much to address the issues people have with abortion.

The problem is it's not "politically feasible" to make the obvious point that their is not rational reason to oppose abortion up to 20wks, or in cases of terminal congenital conditions, or where the health of the mother is at risk. If this was sayable then we have to acknowledge that, the theistic counter arguments are irrational, and nobody in politics wants to get caught saying that.

The abortion "debate" is just another example of how religion, and our cultural deference to it, destroys civil discourse.

quantumushroomsays...

So you are aware that contraception is not 100%?

Between a man with a vasectomy and wearing a condom and a woman on the pill or ring, if she still gets knocked up, the kid should be named Houdini. There's also the morning after pill. And nowhere do I make the claim to oppose all abortion., just the skull-drilling murders of fully-formed children exiting the womb.

And you are aware that despite there being a multitude of forms of contraception out there, people still make mistakes? You are aware that sometimes having a baby when you make a mistake ISN'T the best option right?

An illegitimacy rate in the Black community alone approaching 70% doesn't add up to mere "mistakes" but a sanctioned way of life. Liberal dogma fosters irresponsibility, ignorance, a victim mentality and dependency on the State. Everyone has to pay for these FUCKUPS in addition to their own taxed-to-death families. Unsurprisingly, there weren't as many FUCKUPS when they had to pay for the kids themselves.

You are not excused from being a responsible individual just because you fancy yourself a liberal "rebel". Pay for the abortion OR the kid yourself.

dgandhisays...

>> ^quantumushroom:
And nowhere do I make the claim to oppose all abortion., just the skull-drilling murders of fully-formed children exiting the womb.


Let us be clear the vast majority of late term abortions are cases of terminal congenital conditions, or medical needs of the mother (like going on chemo) nobody who does not want to have a baby waits that long unless they are dirt poor and all the doctors willing to perform one have been run out of town by operation rescue.

An illegitimacy rate in the Black community alone approaching 70% doesn't add up to mere "mistakes" but a sanctioned way of life.

70% of unmarried black women in the US in 2004 had given birth to children while unmarried, but it is not the case that 70% of black children are born to unwed mothers. This number is going down, and has been since the early '90s. Black women are also much less likely to take advantage of abortion services, so that could very easily be the cause of the disparity between 68.8% for unwed black women and 30.5% for unwed white women.

Liberal dogma fosters irresponsibility, ignorance, a victim mentality and dependency on the State. Everyone has to pay for these FUCKUPS in addition to their own taxed-to-death families.

What makes you think black kids with one mom cost you more than white kids with 2.5 parents?

Unsurprisingly, there weren't as many FUCKUPS when they had to pay for the kids themselves.

The '96 welfare reform bill pulled back a lot of gov assistance to single mothers, and somehow magical caused a drop in unwed pregnancy.. starting FOUR YEARS BEFORE it was passed. Unwed motherhood spiked, across ethnic lines, in '91 so please oh great and powerful rationalizer of right wing ideology explain that and how it was a clear cause effect with some evil liberal policy signed by GHW Bush.

Send this Article to a Friend



Separate multiple emails with a comma (,); limit 5 recipients






Your email has been sent successfully!

Manage this Video in Your Playlists




notify when someone comments
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
  
Learn More