Hey do you still have the video of Roger Ebert's Welcome To The Dollhouse review on Siskel And Ebert? I see you uploaded it ages ago but the link seems dead.

Comment hidden because you are ignoring dag. (show it anyway)

True. But if Siskel and Ebert did agree, it was definitely a winner. Miss those guys.

All these reviews and ratings from various sources (even people who I know) don't always match. Show us your ratings and reviews, and let's compare. Even Siskel and Ebert don't always agree with each other.

Roger Ebert pushed rated A for adult which is genius imo.

Tags for this video have been changed from 'Siskel, Ebert, Star Wars' to 'gene Siskel, roger Ebert, Star Wars, john simon' - edited by xxovercastxx

I can't say I agree with Simon, but I certainly don't agrfee with Ebert, Siskel, or (sorry) bluecliff. Star Wars was pretty crappy when it first came out, in every way but special effects, and none of the subsequent episodes got any better. A trite, cliched story combined with wooden acting and moronic, stilted dialog don't make for a good time, in my opinion.

The shameless flipflopping and revisionist history Lucas presented over the years since then pretty well sealed my distaste. First, it had nothing to do with Campbell's Hero's Journey (my guess is that he had no idea who Campbell was at that time), then later, when Campbell became such a fad, well of -course- it was inspired by the Hero's Journey all along. Even Hollywood types should be able to provide a better fake sincerity than Lucas.

Your video, Siskel and Ebert defend Star Wars, has made it into the Top 15 New Videos listing. Congratulations on your achievement. For your contribution you have been awarded 1 Power Point.

As someone who loves Star Wars I don't think the critic was snooty at all. Ebert and Siskel are 2nd rate, populist dudes (which doesn't mean I don't like them - I just recognize what they ARE)...

Star Wars is good. It's just that it really does belong to a dehumanized era, which IS (also) childish...

but we late humans are both of those things... and Star Wars is one of the best dehumanized/childish art options around...

"Dirty Harry (Schtung Chinese New Year Remix)":

Erhu: Hou Shih Chieh
Keyboards: Johnny Yim
Percussion: Tung Tang
Guzheng: Morton Wilson
Chorus: Jaxqueline Fu, Mazy Yap, and the Lok Sin Tong Primary School
Rap: MC Yan
Chorus Lyrics: Chantal Sun
Programming & Mix: Tung Tang
Produced by Ann Yeung & Tung Tang
Executive Producers: Morton Wilson & Hans Ebert
Mixed at Schtung Music Ltd, Hong Kong.

Available on 'D-Sides', I'm told.

4 more comments have been lost in the ether at this killed duplicate.

This video has been seconded as a duplicate; transferring votes to the original video and killing this dupe - dupeof seconded with isdupe by chicchorea.

Tags for this video have been changed from 'gene siskel, roger ebert, peter weller, paul verhoeven' to 'peter weller, paul verhoeven, Robocop, Snow White, Withnail And I' - edited by chingalera

*kill....Roger Ebert, R.I.P.

wtf. This is how I find out Roger Ebert died.

I saw this movie in theatres (Ebert cred).