Here's another game. Let's see if this is easier.

You are offered a choice of two items. You choose one and then offer the next sifter a choice of two items.

1st sifter:     Jon Stewart or Stephen Colbert?

2nd sifter:    Jon Stewart.

                    Cat or Dog?

3rd sifter:     Dog.

                    Music Video or Live Music?

OK, your turn! :D