Not yet a member? No problem!
Sign-up just takes a second.
Forgot your password?
Recover it now.
Already signed up?
Log in now.
Forgot your password?
Recover it now.
Not yet a member? No problem!
Sign-up just takes a second.
Remember your password?
Log in now.
14 Comments
mxxconsays...Star Trek is better!
antsays...Spoilers! *scifi *parody *comedy *wtf *geek
Star Trek won!
siftbotsays...Adding video to channels (Comedy, Geek, Parody, Scifi, Wtf) - requested by ant.
mxxconsays...It's not a spoiler if it's always been true!
Spoilers! *scifi *parody *comedy *wtf *geek
antjokingly says...Get out.
It's not a spoiler if it's always been true!
ChaosEnginesays...upvote for rikers leg!
That was awesome. I'm a fan of both, and Trek is definitely nerdier, but "nerdier" doesn't equal "worse".
Sylvester_Inksays...Considering the dick-waiving that the whole Star Trek vs Star Wars thing always devolves into, I actually enjoyed the light-heartedness of this skit.
That said, the purpose of the stories told by each is meant to be completely different. That Star Wars goes for the simpler, classic hero's journey doesn't make it a lesser work, it just has a more singular focus, and the original trilogy did it well. But when you have a strong foundation like that, you really can't expand on it without losing a lot of the charm of the basic story. That's part of why the sequels were so disappointing. They couldn't retell the hero's journey without being a rehash, and by focusing on the hero's downfall, they had to up the complexity of the plot. But how complex can you make a plot before it just drags the movie down? (The exception was Clone Wars, which was able to circumvent this because it had more space to tell the story.)
This is why I am fairly certain that the new Star Wars movies will be lacking. They can either go the simple route and end up with a rehash, or the complex route, and end up with a similar mess to the prequels. There's a fine line they need to ride in order to make a good set of movies, but there are a lot of things working against them, from the expectations of the Star Wars fans, to the concessions writers have to make to appeal to the mass audience of modern movies. (To say nothing of Abrams, whose insultingly abysmal treatment of Star Trek gives me little confidence.)
Now on the Star Trek end, the stories are meant to be more complex, with commentaries on philosophy, modern politics, and the human condition (as well as showing the unique technological possibilities that the future held). Most of the stories were designed for introspection, and that's a major part of what made the show popular.
But if you lose that introspection and focus on action and special effects, the stories become empty. This is why many of the later movies, which again had to focus on mass appeal, were so lacking. (Movies like Wrath of Khan, Undiscovered Country, Generations, and First Contact avoided this because they were able to draw on the richness of the show to round out the themes they were trying to express, but even still, they weren't quite up to par to the shows when it came to the fundamental concepts of Star Trek.) The same goes for much of Voyager and Enterprise, which often ended up going more for appeal than intellect. (Perhaps the writers ran out of things to say, perhaps the audience just got dumber, who knows.)
So in the end, which one is nerdier? Star Trek, hands down, and as ChaosEngine said, it's a good thing.
Which one is better? That depends on what kind of story you're looking for.
But in the end, there's no denying . . .
Riker is a freaking boss.
Bruti79jokingly says...Shampoo is better. It goes on first and cleans the hair.
poolcleanersays...Conditioner is better. It leaves the hair silky and smooth.
Shampoo is better. It goes on first and cleans the hair.
Sarzysays...OH REALLY FOOL
Conditioner is better. It leaves the hair silky and smooth.
00Scud00says...They forgot the part at the end where the rest of the non sci-fi watching world chimes in to remind them that both sides are a bunch of nerds as far as they are concerned.
Paybacksays...Instant upvote. Loved the panicked look as he couldn't find something to Cpt. Morgan on.
upvote for rikers leg!
Bruti79says...REALLY!
OH REALLY FOOL
siftbotsays...1 more comment have been lost in the ether at this killed duplicate.
Discuss...
Enable JavaScript to submit a comment.