Teen Sings "Non Traditional" Nat'l Anthem and is Scolded

She is told she has to sing it "traditional" or not at all. Racism, I'm thinking.

This young girl's reaction, according to the story below:

Warfield-Cross, who is a member of the high school's choir and has performed with the Bloomington Playwrights Project, said she felt "really confused" after the discussion.

"I felt bad, like I was doing something wrong," she said.

From the AP story:
An Indiana school district that told a black teenager to perform "The Star-Spangled Banner" in a "traditional way" after receiving complaints about her performance is drawing questions now about whether the complaints and directive were racially motivated.

Shai Warfield-Cross, 16, has performed the national anthem at sports events at Bloomington High School North over the last year without incident. But school officials said they received complaints about her performance during a game in Martinsville.

Principal Jeff Henderson told The Herald-Times in a statement that people had complained that while the words to the anthem were the same, the tune was unrecognizable. He declined to comment to The Associated Press.

Some who complained after the game in Martinsville - a predominantly white community about 30 miles southwest of Indianapolis - also said they felt the rendition was disrespectful to current and former members of the military, Henderson said.

Warfield-Cross' family says athletics director Jen Hollars told the teen last Friday that she would not be allowed to sing the anthem unless she modified her version and sang in a more traditional way. Hollars declined to comment and referred questions to Henderson, who said school officials told Warfield-Cross the performances should be more "traditional" to ensure the song's tune is recognizable.

"She was not told that she would no longer be allowed to perform," he said. "She was given guidelines that we hoped she would follow. She performed the next night using those guidelines and she sang beautifully."

Aurora Marin, the teen's stepmother, told The Herald-Times that the directive denies Warfield-Cross her "rights of expression and individuality." The family has written a letter to school officials seeking an apology.

"The national anthem is a historical symbol for our country for independence. The irony is that Shai is being denied her right of artistic expression as a result of her natural voice and cultural heritage," they wrote.

"The situation really makes us question the staff and leadership there, and what their representation of diversity is," Marin said.

Khalil Muhammad, an Indiana University history professor, said he listened to a version of the anthem sung by Warfield-Cross on YouTube and concluded it was "a fairly traditional rendition." He noted that many artists, including Jimi Hendrix, Marvin Gaye and Jose Feliciano, have put their own stamp on the song without significant controversy. Musicians have also performed the song using traditional Jewish musical styles, he added.

Muhammad also questioned the complaint that Warfield-Cross' version was disrespectful to military members.

"African-Americans die in our wars like white Americans," Muhammad said. "Since Vietnam, African-Americans have served disproportionately in our armed services."

Warfield-Cross, who is a member of the high school's choir and has performed with the Bloomington Playwrights Project, said she felt "really confused" after the discussion.

"I felt bad, like I was doing something wrong," she said.
probiesays...

Not a fan of coloratura in *any* song. Take that, Christina Aguilera!

(But that doesn't mean she doesn't get to sing it the way she wants to. It just means her version is gonna suck to my ears.)

srdsays...

>> ^blankfist:
Would be a great world if the borders all went away.


Ahh, but what about the fatal flaw in that world? No more borders means nothing left to keep the worlds armies from clashing.

(Although I _would_ want to watch that if they got equipped with Nerf versions of their original weapon systems.)

Fusionautsays...

For the most part she is just doing some variations on the traditional melody and throwing a LOT of melismas for decoration. Unfortunately she started in a key that was too low for her voice which doesn't allow her to sing the lowest note of the tune and is forced to sing a higher note. (the third of the chord instead of the root) The opening notes are a good example of this and it makes it hard to recognize the melody since she's not singing the complete major triad that starts off the tune. That's the only thing really different in her version but since it's the very beginning of the piece, and it is so recognizable, people listen for it to establish the key and sing along. Other than that she's young and inexperienced and may not be formally trained so her teachers should encourage her to continue learning instead of discouraging her. It's very possible that some elderly person was really annoyed by the opening, then became even more annoyed by all of the variation, couldn't sing along, and was so upset by the end that s/he just had to complain. Older people complain about music ALL of the time for various reasons and the best thing to do is tell them you'll change it for next time. Anyways, rant, rant, rant, rant, rant, rant.....

Send this Article to a Friend



Separate multiple emails with a comma (,); limit 5 recipients






Your email has been sent successfully!

Manage this Video in Your Playlists




notify when someone comments
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
  
Learn More